At what headcount do you switch from trays to individual boxes?

2026 Nov 9th

At what headcount do you switch from trays to individual boxes?

The question

At what headcount do you switch from trays to individual boxes?

The short answer

I get asked this a lot here in Canada by caterers planning drop-offs.

It is not the headcount, it is the pickup window. Trays are fine up to forty if everyone eats at once.

From about fifteen, boxes win when people drift over an hour. A shared tray gets picked over and portions drift, while the last box still looks fresh.

Asked on r/catering

Watch the 30-second version

Frequently Asked Questions

These FAQs answer real searched questions about the product first. A source is linked where an answer cites one.

At what headcount do you switch from trays to individual boxes?
It is not the headcount. It is the pickup window. Trays are fine up to about forty guests if everyone eats at once. From about fifteen people, boxes win when guests drift in over an hour. A shared tray gets picked over, while the last box still looks fresh. See kraft #3 take-out boxes.
When are catering trays still the right choice?
Trays work when the group eats at the same time, including drop-offs up to about forty people with a single pickup window. The problem starts when people arrive over an hour and a shared tray is picked over. For staggered service, switch to individual boxes. Shop disposables for box sizes.
When do individual boxes beat trays for a drop-off?
From about fifteen guests, boxes win when people drift in over an hour. Each late arrival still gets a box that looks fresh, instead of the last of a picked-over tray. Use that rule for Canadian drop-off catering, not a raw headcount. The #3 kraft box covers most single-item portions.
Why does a shared tray look worse as guests arrive late?
A shared tray gets picked over and portions drift as people serve themselves at different times. The last guest sees an uneven tray, while an individual box still looks as packed as the first one. That is why boxes win on a long pickup window, even at a modest headcount. See #3 take-out boxes.
What box size should I use for individual catering portions?
A numbered kraft #3 box, 8.5 × 6.25 in and 200 per case, covers most single-item and small combo drop-offs. Step up to a #8 (850 mL) or #4 when the portion is larger. Match the box to the food, then use boxes whenever the pickup window stretches. Shop #8 kraft boxes for full meals.
Can I use trays and boxes at the same event?
Yes. Use trays where everyone eats at once, and boxes for guests who will arrive later or take food away. The switch is about the pickup window, not a single headcount rule. From about fifteen people on a long window, boxes should already be in the plan. See disposables and kraft take-out box sizes.
Are kraft boxes better than trays for food that sits out?
For a staggered pickup, yes, because each box stays closed and looks fresh until that guest arrives. A tray is fine only if the group eats together, up to about forty people. Pack late-arriving portions in boxes so they are not left on an open tray. Shop #3 kraft boxes.
Do take-out boxes ship to Canadian caterers from Calgary?
Yes. Case orders of kraft boxes ship from our Calgary warehouse to destinations we serve. Pallet freight stays inside Canada and usually needs a dock. Contact us with the box size and event timing, or start with the #3 box case.

References: Health Canada - Food Chemical Contaminants - CFIA - Food Safety for Industry - CFIA - Food Safety for Industry.